Lost the delivery Mud Pies? Buy replacements from the seller

Replace the missing pies before finishing deliveries

1. Check the unfinished delivery objective and your inventory to establish how many pies you still need.
2. Return to the seller who supplied the task’s Mud Pies.
3. Choose the lost-pies conversation; the community quest entry records the wording “I lost the pies...”.
4. Check the offered price and buy the missing quantity. The reported price is 350 Gold Petals per pie.
5. Keep the replacements for the remaining hand-ins and check the journal after each delivery.

Budget for replacements rather than restarting immediately

In Dustin’s example, he had delivered four pies and then used the remaining three on plants. Three replacements at the reported price cost 1,050 Gold Petals. That is an example from his save, not a rule that everyone will be missing three. If money is the obstacle, use the selling-well controls and keep items needed by your other active tasks.

Keep delivery pies separate from gardening supplies

The recovery report shows that these pies could be consumed during planting; do not assume the game will protect every task item. Keep the replacement quantity for deliveries. For ordinary seeds, use the separate planting and watering sequence; buying more seeds does not replace a missing delivery pie.

If the replacement conversation is missing

This answer applies to an active Mud Pie delivery task. Check the current journal stage and that you returned to the original seller. If the branch still does not appear, preserve your save and report the objective text and installed version. The sources do not establish a free replacement, a reset command or a universal fix for a missing NPC hand-in.